Pauled it!
"Pauling it", or, to "Paul it", is a phrase used by the Continue? cast to describe someone making an easily avoidable mistake. The phrase was first used during their play of Battle Kid: Fortress of Peril, when Paul made an easily avoidable mistake that resulted in the death of his character.
Battle Kid Fortress of Peril (NES) - Continue?
Paul takes this good-natured rib in stride and even uses the term himself when another member of the cast "Pauls it".